Malaysia’s Institute for Democracy and Economic Affairs (Ideas) are among free-market think tanks globally that have received donations from tobacco companies and had opposed measures to curb smoking such as higher cigarette taxes, a report by The Guardian highlighted today.
The UK daily had identified Ideas’ statements and work in objecting to the Malaysian government’s 2017 proposal to impose a hike in cigarette tax, in the latter’s bid to cut down on the death toll of over 27,200 Malaysians annually from smoking.
Malaysia’s then deputy health minister Hilmi Yahaya had in March 2017 spoke of plans to increase the price of a pack of cigarettes from RM17 to RM21.50, with The Guardian noting that experts had backed taxes as a proven measure to reduce smoking and smoking-related health problems and deaths.
But the-then Ideas executive director Wan Saiful Wan Jan had reportedly opposed the idea, saying that the proposed solution of higher taxes was “wrong because it will only encourage illegal activities without reducing the number of smokers”, with the argument that “one out of every two packs” of cigarettes in Malaysia is smuggled and a tax hike would boost the illicit trade.
The Guardian noted that the Malaysian government withdrew itheir proposal for higher cigarette taxes after 10 days, but said Ideas continued to speak up for months against the idea by issuing statements, opinion pieces and two reports which used tobacco firm-funded data to say taxes would intensify illegal trade.
The newspaper cited South-east Asia Tobacco Control Alliance’s senior policy adviser Mary Assunta as commenting on Ideas’ work: “The obvious question is: Why the sudden keen interest in tobacco control?”
“[It] coincides with when it started receiving funds from transnational tobacco companies”, she was quoted as saying.
Assunta noted Ideas’ status as a high-profile think tank in Malaysia when arguing that its selection by the tobacco companies to front their position is similar to the latter’s strategy in other countries.
“A 2014 Philip Morris International (PMI) strategy to counter the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control states it should find ‘allies that cannot be ignored’, and Ideas fits this criterion in Malaysia”, she said, referring to a major tobacco firm’s strategy.
The Guardian pointed out that the tobacco industry had funded two separate findings that supported its stand of high smuggling rates of cigarettes in Malaysia, with Nielsen stating a 57.1 percent in smuggling rates and consultancy firm Oxford Economics saying that 52.3 percent of cigarettes here were smuggled.
The newspaper also noted that Nielsen’s spokesperson had said they were unable to share the report and referred the newspaper to the Confederation of Malaysian Tobacco Manufacturers when it tried to obtain a copy, while also highlighting that a Swiss-based PMI affiliate called Philip Morris International Management had paid for Oxford Economics’ report.
Interestingly, the UK paper pointed out that a 2016 estimate by market research company Euromonitor International said tobacco smuggling in Malaysia was closer to 35 percent.
Citing Ideas’ own financial disclosures, The Guardian said the think tank accepted funds from Philip Morris Singapore and Philip Morris Malaysia and that such funds from the Philip Morris International affiliates were during the 2015-2017 period, as well as funds from Japan Tobacco International in 2015 and 2017.
The Guardian said British American Tobacco had replied that they had given donations to Ideas, but did not state which years the donations were made.
In its examination of free-market think tanks worldwide, the newspaper’s analysis revealed at least 106 free-market thinktanks around the world took positions aligned with the tobacco industry in the last decade, accepted donations from the tobacco industry or both.
Reporting by the Observer last year had also shown how the Foreign Office championed British American Tobacco’s interests abroad.
It also said at least 30 free-market think tanks – including Ideas – were among the 47 think tanks who sent a letter in 2016 to the World Health Organisation to oppose the idea of plain packaging for cigarettes, and that Ideas had signed a second letter to the WHO in 2018 to again oppose plain packaging.
Shame on Ideas!
If we say we know that cigarettes are killing us, then we should have the political will to outlaw the tobacco industry and totally stop the sale of these cancer sticks!